When an unexpected guest arraives at Wayfarers Inn, claiming not to remember anything about his past, Tess and her friends are intrigues and slightly suspicious. Meanwhile, the Inn Crowd plans for their first-ever Easter egg hunt and they discover a more likeable side to their news nemesis, Karl Mannus, when he stays at the inn with his wife. However, Karl starts chasing down a story that could shatter a venerable Marietta family.